Homemade Vanilla

10 May
homemade vanilla

After five months... it's awesome

You know, the more I do this DIY stuff, the more I realize how many things I buy out of sheer laziness and lack of planning. For example, vanilla.

It’s absurdly, laughably easy to make. I saw this post over on the ReadyMade blog about how to do it, and quite literally laughed out loud. Because, who knew it was just two readily available ingredients? (Answer: ReadyMade.)

Anyway, in a Sign From The Universe, right around the time I discovered the recipe for making vanilla, I also discovered that They (the makers of most vanillas that you buy in the spice aisle) jazz it up with sugar and/or corn syrup. Really?


In fact, it was an advertisement that clued me into it. Vanilla Maker A claimed their product, made with love and sugar, was better than Vanilla Maker B’s product, which was made with less love because of the corn syrup. Let’s just put aside the whole sugar/corn syrup debate for a minute to ponder why, why, why would someone want to sweeten their vanilla?

I mean, doesn’t vanilla usually go into things that are ALREADY sugared? Like, cookies, cakes, pies, custards, waffles, [fill in your favorite desert here], etc… Why do we need to further sweeten ourselves? DO we need the sugar in vanilla to make it taste good?

So. I decided to try making my own vanilla, full of love but lacking in sugar and corn syrup. And thus, we come to…

Challenge: Vanilla

The store-bought vanilla contains water, glucose, propylene glycol, vanilla extract (alcohol, water, extractive of vanilla beans), alcohol, artificial flavor and caramel color.


The homemade vanilla, following the instructions of the ReadyMade folk, contains:
8 oz. vodka
3 vanilla beans

And here’s how you put them together:

sterilizing the bottle

We use food-grade sanitizer, but hot, soapy water works, too.

First, clean and sterilize your storage vessel. I’m using a pudgy little glass bottle that once held ginger ale. I love these bottles.

slicing the vanilla

The cut doesn't have to be perfect - it just has to exist.

Next, slice the vanilla beans down the middle, the long way, leaving about ½ in. at each of the ends intact.

pouring in the vodka

A cup for the vanilla, a cup for you...

Put the vanilla beans in the storage vessel. (I had to cut mine in half to make them fit.) Add your cup of vodka (I used Smirnoff, because that’s what we keep on hand). Seal. Store in a cool, dry, dark area for at least 8 weeks. Try to resist the temptation to open and smell the vanilla.

store your vanilla for a while

Now, you wait. And wait. And wait.

That’s it. Waaaay easier than pie.

Time and Cost Comparison

The vanilla we have is the Watkins Double Strength Vanilla, and it’s $15.99 for 11 oz. That works out to… $1.45 per ounce.

The homemade vanilla cost $10.40 for 3 vanilla beans and 1 cup of vodka, and made 8 oz, which works out to $1.30 per ounce. It took me about 8 minutes to put together (and some of that time was snapping photos!), and it sat in the cupboard for about 9 weeks before the initial taste test.

For further comparison, I found a bottle of gourmet, no-additives vanilla (ingredients: alcohol and vanilla beans) at the grocery store. The cost was $7.50 for 2 ounces, which worked out to $3.75 per ounce. Ouch.

Ingredient Comparison

The store-bought vanilla contains several ingredients not found in the homemade version: glucose, which is sugar; propylene glycol, which is an additive used either as a humectant or an emulsifier; water; artificial flavors; and caramel color.

Nutritional Comparison

It’s a flavoring used by the teaspoon. It perhaps adds a calorie or two.

Taste Comparison

tasting vanilla

Mmmmm... vanilla-y.

My first attempt at a taste comparison involved trying a half-teaspoon of each type. And you know what? They both tasted like vodka. (Go figure).

For taste test number two, I made a batch of Chantilly cream, which is a fancy-pants way of saying I bought heavy cream, whipped it up, and added a little sugar. Then I divided it among two bowls, added one vanilla to one bowl, and the other vanilla to the other bowl, and then made a bunch of people try it.

Verdict was: The homemade vanilla was preferred for its cleaner flavor. The other vanilla tasted sweeter, but also a bit artificial. (However, let it be noted that one taster felt that if he didn’t know which was which, he’d probably prefer the artificial, because it was the flavor he was used to.)

PITA Factor

1. Perhaps even less than one. So low as to be miniscule. If Miles the Dog had opposable thumbs, he could make it.

DIY or Buy?

DIY. Make your own vanilla. It’s utterly, ridiculously easy; there’s a significant cost savings; you get a cleaner flavor; and you don’t get all the artificial stuff. Yes, it takes a little planning (if you’re out now, you’ll have to wait at least 8 weeks until a homemade batch is ready) but it’s worth it. (PS – Chantilly cream is awesome with vanilla in it. DIY that too.)

Have you tried making vanilla? Any creative thoughts on what I should do with all this vanilla (beyond baking with it)? Please share!


5 Responses to “Homemade Vanilla”

  1. Thisbearbites 05/10/2011 at 10:56 am #

    What you do with all that vainlla is make home made ice cream! Then invite all sorts of people over for a taste test!

    • amanda 05/10/2011 at 11:04 am #

      Oooh, yes! Homemade vanilla ice cream sounds divine. Especially as we head into summer… Now I just have to find a good recipe for it!

  2. Brett Trout 05/11/2011 at 1:56 pm #

    Great job. Martha will be all over this one. Since you are going to fill the bottle up with vodka anyway, would a few rinses with vodka work in lieu of soap or a commercial disinfectant?

    • amanda 05/15/2011 at 1:15 pm #

      That would work… but why waste the vodka? 🙂

  3. Stephanie F 06/21/2011 at 10:34 am #

    So what you really made was vanilla extract, right? I always buy vanilla extract rather than vanilla flavoring and it’s so expensive! Good to know that it’s so easy to make. And what an awesome little Christmas gift to share with people, no?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: